Saying goodbye: A review of Pink Floyd’s “The Endless River”


Pink Floyd. What more do you really need to say other than that? This is the band that re-invented the way that we view music as an artform and a statement of the imagination. Pink Floyd challenged musicians to say more than they already were and audiences to open their hearts and minds to something totally beyond words. You can talk on and on about the landmark albums, the band infighting (i.e. the battle between David Gilmour and Roger Waters), the brilliance, and the tragedy…

But this would only scratch the surface.

So here we are…the final album. The Endless River is not what people expected to hear I think, at least based on the reviews. Consider the following:

“After listening on Spotify, I wanted my time, if not the pennies destined for the band’s coffers, back.”-The Los Angeles Times

“It would take a Barrett-load of drugs to make this sound remotely interesting, though I wouldn’t advise that.”-The Telegraph

“Too often “familiar” curdles into “lazy.”-Pitchfork Media

Ouch, I mean, OUCH. I wonder what album these reviewers were listening to that caused them to come up with such harsh words? The reality is The Endless River is an echo of the past, an introspective look into the musical world Pink Floyd created. It is entirely instrumental with the exception of some spoken word and choral effects, as well as the last track “Louder than Words” which hearkens back very much to the sounds and vocals we so dearly loved on Dark Side of the Moon. People expecting anthems like “Time,” “Shine on You Crazy Diamond,” or “Brain Damage/Eclipse” should erase their pre-conceptions. This is an exploration, not an album made for top 20 hits on the Billboard charts. Simply put, this record is intended as a goodbye, in many ways as well as a dedication to late keyboardist Richard Wright.

thDavid Gilmour himself explained that The Endless River was a “swan song” for Wright, which should explain to the confused listener expecting anthems why none exist here. This record is not FOR us, it is for the band. They are saying goodbye to their bandmate, are closing the book on an astonishing career, and allowing us a glimpse inside. The songs are bits and pieces collected from the various epochs (especially the 1993 and 1994 Division Bell sessions), and twist and turn to the cries of Gilmour’s guitar (easily some of his most expressive playing), the echoes of Wright’s keys (from recordings made before his death), the ambient tones of a plethora of classical, electronic, and jazz instruments and so much more.

This record takes you on a journey that allows your spirit to soar, weep, dream, believe, and think. David Gilmour himself stated that “Unapologetically, this is for the generation that wants to put its headphones on, lie in a beanbag, or whatever, and get off on a piece of music for an extended period of time. You could say it’s not for the iTunes, downloading-individual-tracks generation.” You are brought to so many different levels of emotion and thought; you just have to embrace it.


It is perhaps easier for me to embrace this record for what it is as I create ambient/experimental instrumental music that features all sorts of sounds (often with my guitar wailing in the background). This is in many ways the album that I, as a guitarist and composer so heavily influenced by Pink Floyd and David Gilmour, always wanted from this band. The record feels like the epilogue of an epic novel, and in many ways that is what it is. There is nothing left to be said, Pink Floyd has changed and created music in such a way that it will ripple through the fabric of time long after we all leave this earth. I don’t always have a spiritual feeling with music, but sometimes music can grab my soul and envelop it in something mysterious. The Endless River does this for me.

You don’t have to agree with me, but just give this album a chance if you have not already. The record is truly an exploration into what we perceive an album to be, and fittingly closes the end of the story. Pink Floyd can now, after all the love and tears, say goodbye. I will conclude this review with the lyrics from “Louder than Words,” because as it ends The Endless River, it just makes sense to do the same with my thoughts on the record. The message in these words is very much what this record stands for symbolically:

It’s louder than words
This thing that we do
Louder than words
The way it unfurls
It’s louder than words
The sum of our parts
The beat of our hearts
Is louder than words
Louder than words

Louder than words
This thing they call soul
Is there with a pulse
Louder than words
Louder than words

Goodbye friends, goodbye indeed.




2 thoughts on “Saying goodbye: A review of Pink Floyd’s “The Endless River”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s